NFL teams reject proposal for fourth-and-20 onside kick alternative

NFL Rejects Eagles Proposal for Onside Kick Alternative, Leaves Scoring Teams at Their Own 20-Yard Line”.

The NFL has once again rejected an alternative to the onside kick, despite the fact that recovery rates have become increasingly difficult. The Eagles proposed a new rule that would allow teams to line up their offense on the field on fourth-and-20 instead of kicking off, but it was rejected at a league meeting. If this were to have been approved, scoring teams would have had the option to take the ball at their own 20-yard line and face a fourth-and-20.

The NFL has made significant changes to the kickoff over the years, and while recovering onside kicks is almost impossible now, discussions about more alternatives are still taking place. However, whenever proposals for an onside kick alternative are brought up, they do not gain traction. Rich McKay, chairman of the Competition Committee, acknowledged this resistance but stated that discussions about more options will happen in the future.

The league’s primary concern at present is deciding what to do with the kickoff itself, as they are considering shifting towards a low-impact kickoff rule similar to what was previously used in the XFL. This change could potentially help reduce injuries and increase player safety during kickoffs.

For now, no alternatives to the onside kick have been approved by the NFL. The league will need to determine its rules for the 2024 season before revisiting any changes related to onside kicks or kickoffs in general.


As a content writer at, I am Samantha Johnson—a wordsmith with a fervent love for storytelling and a keen eye for captivating readers. With a diverse background in journalism and digital marketing, I craft compelling narratives that engage, inform, and inspire our audience. Whether unraveling breaking news stories or delving into thought-provoking features, my aim is to deliver content that resonates and leaves a lasting impact. Join me on a journey through the ever-evolving landscape of news and narratives at